Wow, what a brutal business to be in! With my stuff, people would have to back up a truck to take that many dollars worth!
So, I tried a return in v14. It seems that the question lies in what happens once you get the credit for the return showing up in the sales window.
I can start a new transaction, and the return remains available to finish later.
If I Clear Sale, the return is cleared. No more sign of it. I have to say that I've done that myself, just thinking that I didn't do part of it right (or didn't pick the right reason). Somehow it just seems like you should be able to. What happens from there, though, is that:
- when going in to return the item again, if you use the same invoice #, everything looks the same as first time around, EXCEPT that a "1" will show up in the Returned column, essentially telling you that you can't do it again.
- if you look in Customer info in the Advance Payment window, no credit will show up (probably because you didn't get to choose between a store credit and a refund)
- in looking at the daily Returns report, no return shows up
What I've done as a workaround (though I'm not sure it would work for you), is to do another return and skip the invoice # (i.e., use "no receipt"), then I can choose the appropriate item and finish it up that with, with correct customer name and everything.
It probably would be more appropriate to have the Return "finalized" AFTER choosing store credit or refund, but I'll bet Ronald has a reason to not have done it that way.
I hope that addresses what you're trying to address.